2007 - 2020

Things aint wot they used to be

ok-heres-the-thing

The Better Together campaign has launched its strongest defence of the Union yet, warning that an independent Scotland will no longer be allowed to call things ‘things’.

Speaking on the BBC’s Newsnight programme, Better Together’s Alasdair Darling argued, ‘Alex Salmond is pursuing a separatist agenda into the unknown, which means Scots don’t have a clue what’s going to happen about defence, our status in the EU, or even what things are going to be called.’

Pressed by Gordon Brewer on this last point, Darling gestured towards the table in front of them.  ‘Well look, three hundred years of shared history in the Union means that everyone, from Lands End to John O’Groats, can agree that this is called a table.  But what’s it going to be called in an independent Scotland?  A ‘yorrok’?  A ‘mogrump’?  This glass of water could become a ‘deerg’ of ‘klot-juice’ for all we know.  It’s these very uncertainties which are worrying Scots about separatism.’

When the SNP’s John Swinney replied that a table will still be called a ‘table’ in an independent Scotland, he was challenged by the Conservatives’ Ruth Davidson.  ‘Have the SNP checked that with EU lawyers?  In Germany it’s called ‘einen Tisch’.  In Italy it’s ‘una tabella’.  In Spain it’s ‘una mesa’.  Does Alex Salmond seriously think the EU will just automatically allow him to keep on calling it a table?  What kind of independence is this anyway, when Scotland has to ask permission from Brussels to keep on calling things ‘things’?

The overwhelming legal evidence does indeed seem to bear out the Better Together campaign’s point.  When asked if a table is called in Italy ‘una tabella’ several top European lawyers were able to confirm that it is true.

‘It all adds up to another very bad day for the SNP,’ said Labour’s Margaret Curran.  ‘Scots will be appalled to know that they might no longer be able to communicate with their friends and family in the rest of the UK about simple things like tables or glasses of water.  Why break the thousands of strong, traditional links between our nations, of which this is just one?  It might mean, for example, that the next James Bond film is called in Scotland The Unicorn House Rowing Team Adventure or the Olympics renamed, ‘The Fud Games’!  Is that really what most Scots want?

Willie Rennie, of the Scottish Liberal Democrats, has backed up the claim.  ‘Alex Salmond thinks that, after independence, we can just wave a magic wand and things will still be called ‘things’.  He forgets the painstaking process we’ll have to go through.  There are over two million words in the dictionary.  European lawyers will have a field day going through all of them, one by one, in order to check that they can still be called by that name.  How much is that going to cost exactly?’

The official response from the Yes campaign is that, ‘An independent Scotland fully intends for English to remain its first language.’  Darling, however, was quick to attack the SNP’s weak position here: ‘How could Salmond call Scotland independent when our ‘first language’ would be that of another country?  It’s preposterous.  The English language will remain with England, it’s as simple as that.  Fact is, we don’t know what language Scotland will be using because the SNP haven’t invented one yet.’

Editorial, p.7 – ‘Will Scotland one day be called Fred?’

Comments (10)

Join the Discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Bill McLean says:

    Alan – with respect and why not, I fink you mean “fings aint what they used to be”!

    1. bellacaledonia says:

      Headline courtesy of Bella. Its a pun cos thats wot we people want above articles innit?

    2. Digby Bevan says:

      The English don’t seem to have noticed that they no longer have their own language. In exporting their language into many countries around the world, including the other countries in the British Isles, the English lost ownership of their own language. World wide only a small percentage of people who speak English as their first language are English.

  2. vronsky says:

    In Italy it’s ‘una tavola’. Maybe you’re talking about HTML, though. I’m looking forward to seing ” running from the Solway to ” at Berwick.

    http://www.lorenzoroi.net/corso-ip1/tabelle.html

    http://www.lorenzoroi.net/corso-ip1/tabelle.html

  3. Lachie Macquarie says:

    Bord for table, uisge de gloine for glass of water. Obh Obh we do have another language, Let’s all speak Erse?

  4. Dàibhidh Steele says:

    So, what language do they use in the; US, Australia, New Zealand or Canada? Are things really that desperate for the better together campaign?

  5. lauraannham says:

    Oh please. Tables will not be allowed in an independent Scotland as it is too representative of the union. Each table leg, Wales, N Ireland, Scotland and England will be torn from the table top, and handed back to their respective counties and we will eat siting cross legged like the Japanese.

  6. The Japanese do not eat sitting cross-legged. They sit in seiza position when not on a chair. Legs in a bow shape.

  7. DanTDog says:

    hmmm…interesting aside…when I was learning Italian in the 60’s, a table was called “una tavola”… funny how things change… 🙂

  8. Macart says:

    As Benjamin J Grimm would say ‘Whut in the name o’ my aunt Petunia?’ They’ve got to be kidding, surely? DOH! I forgot that as ‘furriners’ we’ll be compelled to speak in heathen tongues.

    If this is the best argument in the armoury they’re in trouble.

Help keep our journalism independent

We don’t take any advertising, we don’t hide behind a pay wall and we don’t keep harassing you for crowd-funding. We’re entirely dependent on our readers to support us.

Subscribe to regular bella in your inbox

Don’t miss a single article. Enter your email address on our subscribe page by clicking the button below. It is completely free and you can easily unsubscribe at any time.