2007 - 2021

Neutral Like a Knife in the Back

If you don’t read the newspaper, you are uninformed.  If you do read the newspaper, you are misinformed.  – Author unknown, commonly attributed to Mark Twain or Thomas Jefferson

The recent stooshie about the Libdems being told to attack the SNP by the Scottish media or receive no coverage may have been disgraceful but it wasn’t particularly surprising to any who keeps an eye on these things.

I’ll give you a quick example.

Every day I get a google alert on the search term “Scottish Independence” so I can see what people are writing on the subject.

I don’t necessarily read all the stories, in fact I tend to concentrate more on the clearly lunatic ones and there are plenty of those.

Nevertheless, a quick analysis of just the titles that come up should show you a pattern.

Bear in mind before you read this that about half the Scottish public voted for an Independence supporting party so you would expect to see that reflected in the title, wouldn’t you?

I’ll list the ones for the last few days, only omitting those that are not actually on the subject of independence. A search can sometimes throw something up that might be along the lines of  “Scottish Schools ask for more Independence from local councils”. Something like that isn’t relevant, so as I said, only omitting those ones lets see what we get…

Peer demands England gets a say on Scottish independence – Herald Scotland

Grassroots campaign to back union – The Press Association

Scotland’s top civil servant faces ‘gone native’ complaints – Telegraph.co.uk

Sir Gus O’Donnell told to ‘read the riot act’ over Scottish independence – Telegraph.co.uk

Scotland debates whether Scottish residents would be better or worse off in an … – PRunderground

Ed Miliband: Independence for Scotland would be ‘a bad idea’ – Scottish Daily Record

SNP budget for big cash switch ‘missing £200m’ – Scotsman

‘Westminster should call Scots independence vote’ – Scotsman

Stay positive to beat SNP, urges Ed Miliband – Scotsman

Independent Scotland Will Have A Catastrophic Debt Burden, Warns Debt … – PRunderground

Concern over ‘independence’ post – BBC News

Exclusive: A war of independence: PM squares up to Salmond – The Independent

Kenny Farquharson: Why Union’s fate depends on Fraser – Scotsman

Both sides of independence debate must be considered – Herald Scotland (oh really?)

Jim Murphy: David Cameron treats Scotland like Slovenia – Telegraph.co.uk

Westminster needs to adopt the ‘Plan MacB’ approach – John O’Groat Journal

Forget SNP rhetoric. Scotland’s public finances are in trouble – The Guardian (blog)

Scots independence: beware your tax bills would be high – Daily Express

Veering a little more one way than the other, aren’t they?

Comments (0)

Join the Discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. BTW, here is today’s selection too…

    Scot independence ‘puts UK at risk’ – The Press Association
    Westminster weighs up holding referendum first – Herald Scotland
    Top civil servant under fire over political impartiality allegations – Herald Scotland
    That’s what we need. More panjandrums – The Guardian
    Freedom for England! From a distinguished liberal writer, a surprising call to … – Daily Mail

  2. bellacaledonia says:

    Good work Michael. Maybe we should cover this weekly.

    “Et tu, John O’Groat Journal?”


  3. Ard Righ says:

    …and there are those who wonder why there is a confidence problem in Scotland and a high suicide rate.

    I have a game, it usually involves taking a title of some pro union propaganda and coming up with the real meaning (usually the exact opposite of the printed projected reality).
    It often boils down to: We are s*** scared of independence for Scotland, because it will be an end to our wholesale theft of resources and domination of Scotland and its people, we’ve ruined the south of Britain, were will we settle our colonists…oooooo the union jack!

    I have enjoyed the parallels when seeing high profile Scots men and women using comparators with Scotland that include Finland, Ukraine, Estonia, Sweden, Norway, Ireland, Iceland, Poland, Lithuania.
    Much more positive and realistic, particularly the seafaring nations that are independent.

Help keep our journalism independent

We don’t take any advertising, we don’t hide behind a pay wall and we don’t keep harassing you for crowd-funding. We’re entirely dependent on our readers to support us.

Subscribe to regular bella in your inbox

Don’t miss a single article. Enter your email address on our subscribe page by clicking the button below. It is completely free and you can easily unsubscribe at any time.