2007 - 2021

Go Your Own Way

All this week we’re publishing articles by English people who support a Yes vote in September.

I drove three hours up the M6/M74 arriving in Glasgow to settle into my uni life in 1999, and soon felt as though I was among my own people. The Scotland v England Euro playoff that followed soon after disavowed me of that fairly quickly, but for the four years I was in Glasgow and beyond I felt very at home, and that as northerner in Scotland I was much closer to my kind than if I’d have gone 200 miles south from Lancashire. The pride felt by west-coasters was easily seen and understood as the infrastructure of the industrial age melted into the reinvented post-European City of Culture to create a modern and confident metropolis which spoke from the heart of a reborn Scotland under the watchful gaze (for as long as his specs were intact) of Donald Dewar, set amidst a stunning country which both inspired and infuriated with its ability to inspire great lyric, or phoney Brigadoon – depending on where you stood.

Seven years after first leaving, I returned to Glasgow in 2010. The post-2008 decline was noticeable, as elsewhere around the UK, but moving up from London it felt that Glasgow had caught the chill harder, the city centre pockmarked by boarded shop fronts and in need of a good scrub. By the time of the 2011 elections, the bravery of Alec Salmond reaped greater reward than even he had imagined as he set out a platform for a socially just Scotland, toning down the Nationalist rhetoric, and the electorate looked on and said ‘yep, that’s where I want to live.’ I had the Today programme on the morning after the night before, and listened on in amazement as Swinney wasted no time in pushing the referendum agenda. This wasn’t what the nation had voted for, certainly not in my Leith constituency. And it was an opinion I held to after yo-yoing back to England.

Back in Manchester as an interested spectator, my support for the status quo has basically been driven by a fear of separation. I have tried to pick holes in Yes, which have been expertly answered with certainty where possible and an acceptance that some things are just unknown, and have slowly come round to the advocates of independence. Influenced by the centre-right or bust nature of Westminster politics, the mess of the No campaign compared to the confident clarity of Yes, but mainly by my belief that a people should take responsibility for themselves. A cursory glance at the history books had me struggling to find a time when a people were given the choice and decided to remain in the keep of another country, and why would they?

This simple philosophical point is the key, why would you not take the opportunity to make things better for you and your community?

There are a lot of figures being thrown around, and my grasp on them doesn’t even qualify as tenuous. If those sums are being done with the A9 corridor, the south-west and borders, northern Fife and Grampian beyond Aberdeen in mind, in addition to the Central belt – to which Scotland is often reduced in the UK setting – then at least the possibility for a Scotland with thriving and modern manufacturing, service and cultural industries is more likely as a country than a region. And if the country can be as brave in its vision as the First Minister was in 2011, the rewards could be just as great.

There is a lot of sneering going on down here, ‘let’s see how the sweaties (socks… jocks, geddit?) manage with all their freebies without hand-outs from London!’ Well yes, let’s. Such a stance is highly problematic, if the question you’re asking is ‘how are they going to pay for no student fees/ free prescriptions/ care for the elderly?’ and not ‘why is health and education not free for all in the rest of our country?’ then I think you’ve lost sight of the real goal of a civilised society. And it is this mentality south of the wall which has given my wavering towards Yes greater enthusiasm and the hope that when the Yes campaign wins on September 18, it will force not only a redrawing of the map, but a re-examination of the way London treats the whole of the UK. And for that, this Caledoniphile will be forever grateful to his friends north of the border.

And if it does turn out well for you, any chance of an expansion into the Northumbrian region?

Comments (0)

Join the Discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. gonzalo1 says:

    A fine and magnanimous article. I have met lots of Northern English and most of them have similar values and ambitions.

    1. Pete Bradley says:

      It isn’t just people from the north of England. It’s people in more or less all of England, indeed anywhere there are decent, rational, civilised people.

  2. Nice article,simple explanation of why yes.Many people in England and indeed the rest of the UK do see that Scottish independence is good for everybody in the UK.The people have been divided by the tactics of the Westminster government,and have been aided and abetted (yes I think its criminal) by a greedy media.We go about asking the constant question of “if only ” they could see what they are doing,or not doing,and the message of yes must be taken to the people directly by-passing the media.The media fail us at almost every turn,they fail in their duty to ask relevant questions of our politicians;one I would like to be answered is the “Faslane question” John Major(the grey man) tells the voters of Scotland “if you throw out Trident the Americans wont forgive us” really? they don’t live here beside these “nukes” but the reporters never ask “what will the rUK do when after a yes vote Scotland keeps Trident and the rUK has no nuclear weapons! will they be tossed out of NATO?! that is the question that the politicians should be answering everytime one of them brings up the NATO membership gambit.

  3. I have said this for long and long. The most significant positive outcome of a Yes vote will be to free England of the ghastly drapes of ‘Britishness’.

    1. Pete Bradley says:

      Nail on head. Of course, that’s the biggest reason why the British ruling classes fear a YES vote. They know that once England loses its ‘Britishness’, the game’s up.

  4. benmadigan says:

    Couldn’t agree more Derick!!

  5. rabthecab says:

    Chapeau sir. An excellent article, one which sees that Independence isn’t the end, but only the beginning. It may well be a hard road ahead, and no one has all the answers, but that’s no reason to vote no.

    “…a people should take responsibility for themselves.” Says it all for me, and I’m sure many others will feel the same.

  6. LMS says:

    Thanks Mike – great article, welcome support….fantastic to get the support of everyone who wishes Scotland well in re-gaining Independence – I truly believe and hope if it’s a YES win come September,it will help other regions of the UK who also are suffering from London centric disadvantage – you’re all welcome to relocate here any day 😀

    1. Pete Bradley says:

      Don’t you mean the other nations of the ‘U’K?

Help keep our journalism independent

We don’t take any advertising, we don’t hide behind a pay wall and we don’t keep harassing you for crowd-funding. We’re entirely dependent on our readers to support us.

Subscribe to regular bella in your inbox

Don’t miss a single article. Enter your email address on our subscribe page by clicking the button below. It is completely free and you can easily unsubscribe at any time.