A Social Policy as if People Really Mattered

Cleo Goodman explains how welfare reform is an essential part of creating a wellbeing economy.

A Basic Income is a regular payment received by every citizen, regardless of their circumstance, from cradle to grave. It is a radical social security reform; a form of emancipatory welfare that ensures everyone has a financial safety net throughout their lives. A Basic Income, as a policy that ensures every member of society has the resources to fulfil their basic needs, supports a wellbeing economy. Scottish Government has allocated £250,000 to explore the feasibility of a Basic Income, which puts us in the running to be the first nation on the planet to implement a Basic Income.

A Basic Income has 5 key characteristics. It is paid regularly, not as a one off or lump sum. It’s paid as cash which can be spent freely, not as vouchers or reimbursement for specific purchases. It is paid to each individual, not the household. It is unconditional; it is not paid in exchange for work, demonstration of a willingness to work or on any other criteria. And it is universal, everyone receives it. These are the fundamentals of a Basic Income; any other elements depend on the model chosen including the level at which the payment is set.

A Basic Income is a genuine safety net through a change in circumstance. If your ability to work is disrupted you are still guaranteed a base level of income. If the paid work on offer does not meet your needs a Basic Income provides the financial support required to say no to it and find more suitable opportunities. A Basic Income gives you more choice over how you spend your time, making unpaid but essential activities like caring, spending time within your community, creativity and volunteering less strained.

Of course, the sum paid dictates the extent to which these benefits are felt, so when designing our Basic Income, we must ask what we want it to do. We then test our models to ensure those aims are met.

Citizen’s Basic Income Network Scotland is a grassroots, volunteer run, educational charity which speaks to hundreds of people about their interest in a Basic Income each year. For most, a Basic Income represents hope. It’s the antithesis of our current welfare system that has fractured into suspicion, invasive assessments and punitive sanctions. Inequality is rife and unnecessary; some people have everything they could ever need and others have nothing. A Basic Income is a simple way to meaningfully redress this and it can’t come quickly enough. There are many future unknowns; automation may eliminate certain jobs, leaving many people without an income. A Basic Income would support us through these changes without creating jobs for jobs’ sake, and instead focus on generating more leisure time and interesting, useful work, focused on people and the planet.

Basic Income is an idea that has gained increasing attention from Cellardyke to Silicon Valley, which has led to four local authorities (Fife, Edinburgh, Glasgow and North Ayrshire) submitting a joint bid to Scottish Government to fund research into whether a Basic Income is right for Scotland. This research is now well under way (see here for first update from the feasibility study) and recommendations on whether a Basic Income experiment should go ahead will be made in March 2020. While this is incredibly exciting, it is only the first step towards Scotland becoming the first nation with a Basic Income. A true commitment to an adequate Basic Income can only happen if citizens are vocal and uncompromising in their support of a fit for purpose Basic Income.

A wellbeing economy is based on decisions that benefit people and planet over profit. For this to work in practice those decisions need to be made on an individual level, as well as collectively. We need to be able to make choices that support our own wellbeing and have opportunities to invest our time in ethical activities. At the moment, our paid work is driven by personal profit; we are pushed into paid work to make enough money to support ourselves. Nothing decimates our individual wellbeing like poverty so we compromise, we do work that is not fulfilling, in environments that are bad for us, for companies we disagree with. We turn a blind eye because we have to pay the bills, because it’s “just a job”.

To shift this we need to fix our institutions, our legislation and our economy to create work that generates social value in a way that does not damage the planet. Alongside this we need to ensure we look after every individual, supporting their ability to choose and to thrive. At the moment, we clamour for personal profit just to survive. A Basic Income would remove this pressure. It would provide an opportunity to pause society’s unhealthy obsession with profit, growth and productivity to consider what really matters. What deserves our time? What desperately needs our attention? If you remove the fear of destitution for the individual, we can realistically and meaningfully prioritise these questions. Without that, a wellbeing economy would be driven from the top down. It would leave people behind, with our most vulnerable impacted most severely. A Basic Income is a tool to bring about a wellbeing economy, and a reminder, for everyone who receives it, why we’re making these choices it in the first place.




Comments (5)

Join the Discussion

Your email address will not be published.

  1. Mark Bevis says:

    Excellent, yes, UBI or CBI whatever you want to call it, is an essential part of the way forward for society in a post-neoliberal world.

    If you think about it objectively, the concept of going to a place of work you don’t like with people you’d never socialise with, to do stuff that you know is wrecking the environment, all to give some paper or electronic tokens to somebody else so you can have the basic essentials of life – in the hope that you’ll have sommat left over at the end – is simply absurd. Cutting out the middleman, ie, money, would save a lot of wasted effort and energy.
    In the interim, a UBI would be the first step in the dissolution of money. By giving everybody it, and thereby giving everybody the opportunity to do what they want, will devalue the concept of money in the long run, and eventually we’ll realise we just don’t need it, nor the elitist patriarchal controlling mechanisms that come with it.

  2. Graeme McCormick says:

    Under my model of Annual Ground Rent I have provided for a UCI of £200 per week for all men , women and children in Scotland. We could do this now.

  3. Josef Ó Luain says:

    Have you spoken to Andrew Wilson about this, Cleo?

    1. Cleo Goodman says:

      Not personally! Sounds like I should though 🙂

  4. Alistair Taylor says:

    Aye, good article.
    I would be happy picking up litter all week long, because it would be a never ending job.
    Or picking fruit, for the common good.
    Growing vegetables, or playing football in the park (while encouraging youngsters).

    Some people, on the other hand, will be happy to pish their weekly allowance away on booze, cigarettes and drugs, and still be in “poverty”.
    It’s a sair fecht, but little by little we’ll get to a healthier society, i hope.

Help keep our journalism independent

We don’t take any advertising, we don’t hide behind a pay wall and we don’t keep harassing you for crowd-funding. We’re entirely dependent on our readers to support us.

Subscribe to regular bella in your inbox

Don’t miss a single article. Enter your email address on our subscribe page by clicking the button below. It is completely free and you can easily unsubscribe at any time.