2007 - 2021

Let Them Eat Cake

The Sun reports that in a cunning move “Ministers have drawn up secret plans to stockpile processed food in the event of EU divorce talks collapsing – to show Brussels that “no deal” is not a bluff. Theresa May has ordered “no deal” planning “to step up” — with the government poised to start unveiling some of the 300 contingency measures in the coming weeks…” (“Grub Stash Plan”).

You’ve got to love the idea that ‘stockpiling’ would keep the food industry afloat – but also the idea that this is going to worry the Brexit negotiators: “We’re so dumb we’ll starve ourselves out” bellowed by Dominic Raab in a splenetic Britannia Unleashed howl is going to have them trembling at our stupidity.

The war-cry “We’ll Siege Ourselves!” has a certain ring to it doesn’t it?

Last night Downing Street said “no deal preparation work is to be stepped up” and led by the far-right new Brexit Secretary Dominic Raab. Yesterday the Cabinet briefed the new ministers on measures Britain is taking, with No 10 saying: “It’s sensible to make preparations for all scenarios and that includes No Deal.”

Yer Super-Soaraway Sun reports: “Emergency measures to keep Britain’s massive food and drinks industry afloat – including stockpiling ahead of exit day on 29 March next year. More than £22 billion worth of processed food and drinks are imported in to the UK – 97 per cent from the EU – in an industry that keeps 400,000 workers employed in the UK. Similar stockpiles are also being prepared for medical supplies amid fears of chaos at British ports next year.”

The scale of food insecurity in Britain – a country in which food supplies has been allowed to be concentrated in a handful of corporations (Tesco, Sainsbury’s, Asda and Morrisons account for a combined market share of almost 77 per cent) – is generally unacknowledged. Combine this with a drastic drop-off in seasonal food workers and an agricultural industry with an ageing and highly precarious farming network and you have a recipe for crisis. With a population hooked on processed food and almost entirely incapable of cooking from fresh produce the No Deal Food Plan looks like a disaster waiting to happen.

Still, this is less important than to maintain and crank up the grievance narrative against Europe in the expectation of a contrived huffy walk-out by British negotiators.

You can only maintain this level of self-delusion and self-harm if you are able to sustain your propaganda across multiple platforms. Today in the Telegraph we are asked to consider if a UK Tory Prime Minister is guilty of “treason”.

The propaganda is being cultivated everywhere in the seamless media Leave hysteria. Over at the Spectator Brendan O’Neill barks:

“There has been a Remainer coup. Remainers now inhabit virtually all of the highest offices in the land. Overnight, adherents to this minority political viewpoint seized the final levers of political power. This is the one downside — and what a downside it is — to the belated outbreak of principle among the cabinet’s Brexiteers: their walking away has allowed Theresa May to further surround herself with fellow Remainers, and pretty much expel the Brexit outlook from her cabinet.”

This is brilliant.

None of this is new. As Ash Sarkar writes: “Boris Johnson was only given a pass on his grotesque racism because of the snivelling class deference of UK political media.”

And neither is the looming food crisis the imagination of dreary Remoaners or catastrophists.

Last year the Science Policy Research Unit published a report which stated that the “UK is unprepared for the most complex ever change to its food system, which will be required before Brexit” (see ‘A Food Brexit: time to get real’.)

The report, by leading food policy specialists Professor Erik Millstone (University of Sussex), Professor Tim Lang (City, University of London) and Professor Terry Marsden (Cardiff University), concluded that leaving the European Union poses serious risks to consumer interests, public health, businesses and workers in the food sector.

The report warned that a “Food Brexit” is of unprecedented importance and is happening at a time when the UK food system is already vulnerable, with self-sufficiency also in decline. Among the issues which the paper urged Ministers to address are needs for:

  • An urgent need for a clear integrated plan for UK food – the UK government currently has no UK food policy
  • Clarification on food crossing borders, particularly from the Republic of Ireland to Northern Ireland
  • New legislation to replace 4,000 pieces of EU law relating to food
  • Scientific and regulatory infrastructure, replacing at least 30 EU-based bodies
  • Farm viability and subsidies to replace the EU’s Common Agricultural Policy (CAP)
  • Fishing policies that are more than rejecting the 1964 pre-EU London Convention
  • Food labour – 35 per cent of food manufacturing labour is from the EU; more in parts of catering and horticulture
  • Some idea of from where UK food will come – as only around 54-61 per cent is currently UK-sourced
  • Tariffs – retail industry says tariffs could raise imported food prices by 22 per cent post-Brexit
  • Prices, which are already rising and likely to rise more, will become more volatile, especially harming poor consumers
  • Quality standards throughout supply chains, which are currently set by the EU, may well decline, and may do so abruptly.

None of these matters have been resolved seriously, instead we are proclaiming the solution to be “stockpiling” food.

Professor Tim Lang said:

“UK food security and sustainability are now at stake. A food system which has an estimated three to five days of stocks cannot just walk away from the EU, which provides us with 31 per cent of our food. Anyone who thinks that this will be simple is ill-informed.”

A No Deal Brexit has direct consequences for the Scottish food industry from deregulation to attacks on provenance and branding and the imposition of GM food, but is also has wider and potentially catastrophic consequences for the basic food supply across the UK.



Comments (15)

Join the Discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Carroll says:

    One and only answer “INDEPENDENCE”

  2. Chris Pilley says:

    See also this on Brexit, food Security and health, just published, warning of the danger of “a severe humanitarian crisis, with widespread food shortages being one of the first manifestations”. https://blog.oup.com/2018/07/brexit-threatens-food-supplies-eu/?utm_source=twitter&utm_medium=oupacademic&utm_campaign=oupblog

  3. SleepingDog says:

    Well, now the UK regime has taken back control, and will no doubt try to fondly emulate its USAmerican role model in contempt of international norms, it can only be a matter of months before the Prize Salvage Act 1948 is repealed and May’s monarch will be signing letters of marque to transform the Royal Navy into provision-pillaging privateers again, to stuff the modern aristocracy’s larders.

    Meanwhile belt-tightening, vegetable-repudiating commoners will hungrily await the arrival of plump EU humanitarian aid workers as in a dim ancestral memory re-enactment of 1950s-1970s disaster science fiction.

    Mothers will be reduced to providing Internet porn services to pay for the expensive baby-moloko formula their corporate masters dictate:
    while the few who survive will remember the warm days suffused with the sweet smell of fruit and vegetables rotting in fields, of piles of discarded household pets, and of spent ammunition around barricaded food stores.

  4. Graeme McCormick says:

    Scotland is better placed than rUK to feed itself given the population food production balance yet well no doubt be expected to perform the Loaves and Fishes miracle to provide for our southern cousins

    1. Graeme – I assure you – having spent a considerable time researching this – that Scotland suffers from exactly the same food insecurity issues as England does. We are also heavily dependent on the same four corporations, vulnerable to crop failures and over-reliance on importation and dependent on foreign migrant workers in agriculture etc etc. Any differences are marginal.

      1. Willie says:

        The ratio of land area to population in Scotland is much more favourable than down south.

        Ditto the availability of water as is also the fishing grounds around our shores and beyond.

        Oil, gas and renewables kind of top off these key ratios.

        But isn’t it harrowing that in the 21st century we are talking about stockpiling food as the Brexit debate begins to resemble 1940s wartime Britain.

        1. There’s quite a gap between a ‘land area to population’ and a functioning food system

          1. Willie says:

            Yes, I quote agree. But Scotland is endowed with resources in ratios that our neighbour can never have.

            Fishing, oil, gas, water, being examples, aside of land.

            We even have deep water ports sufficiently far from major population centres suitable to house nuclear weapon facilities.

            What not to like as we isolate ourselves from Europe.

  5. lordmac says:

    Should Scotland find its self with a no deal, how far would a truck have to go to collect food that had a no deal in Europe,would it be Russia, and at what costs in border crossings ,as I believe their are border fees to be paid, as should you bring a coffin home though Europe.

  6. Jo says:

    All good for the obesity problem tho’ eh?

    1. Willie says:

      There wasn’t an obesity crisis in Ireland when they were, despite the potato blight, exporting wheat and other crop to England..

      A bit like fuel poverty in modern day Scotland… with power from the glen (not) to the glen.

      No doubt post Brexit a trade deal between Boris and Donald we’ll be able to improve on that.

  7. Iain Taylor says:

    I know it’s a childish response, but… Hahahahahahaha.

  8. w.b.robertson says:

    and what will the EU member countries do with all the food that they would normally sell to the UK? and how will a glut on the continent then affect the producers` profit margins? to think anything through in modern society…follow the money!

    1. lordmac says:

      We had mountains of butter,cheese,and Apple’s and handed that to farmers that had pigs, I believe as a gift from the EU to the UK , I am pining my hopes on their generosity once again, after brexit. to prevent another, famine

  9. SleepingDog says:

    All those smugglers’ coves being refitted, all those little ships made seaworthy, all those dark lanterns dusted off…

Help keep our journalism independent

We don’t take any advertising, we don’t hide behind a pay wall and we don’t keep harassing you for crowd-funding. We’re entirely dependent on our readers to support us.

Subscribe to regular bella in your inbox

Don’t miss a single article. Enter your email address on our subscribe page by clicking the button below. It is completely free and you can easily unsubscribe at any time.